Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

A research-level question can also be off-topic if the community has chosen to restrict the scope of the site so. Our help pageshelp pages state that questions about open problems are off-topic, so closing because of that is fine. The standard off-topic closure reason is misleading, so I suggest you vote to close under a custom reason. Choose the option "Other" under "Off-Topic" in the close vote dialogue and write what the problem is. I think this particular reason to close is not so common that we would need a separate closing reason.

I think the particular questionthe particular question would be much better at MSE, which is why I voted to close for that reason. It seemed to me that it would be an acceptable answer that the OP's conjecture turns out to be equivalent with something famous and open, but such an explanation should rather be given at MSE than here. For MO audience I feel that the problem is trivially equivalent to Goldbach's conjecture, but the OP and the average MSE user may not consider it as trivial.

A research-level question can also be off-topic if the community has chosen to restrict the scope of the site so. Our help pages state that questions about open problems are off-topic, so closing because of that is fine. The standard off-topic closure reason is misleading, so I suggest you vote to close under a custom reason. Choose the option "Other" under "Off-Topic" in the close vote dialogue and write what the problem is. I think this particular reason to close is not so common that we would need a separate closing reason.

I think the particular question would be much better at MSE, which is why I voted to close for that reason. It seemed to me that it would be an acceptable answer that the OP's conjecture turns out to be equivalent with something famous and open, but such an explanation should rather be given at MSE than here. For MO audience I feel that the problem is trivially equivalent to Goldbach's conjecture, but the OP and the average MSE user may not consider it as trivial.

A research-level question can also be off-topic if the community has chosen to restrict the scope of the site so. Our help pages state that questions about open problems are off-topic, so closing because of that is fine. The standard off-topic closure reason is misleading, so I suggest you vote to close under a custom reason. Choose the option "Other" under "Off-Topic" in the close vote dialogue and write what the problem is. I think this particular reason to close is not so common that we would need a separate closing reason.

I think the particular question would be much better at MSE, which is why I voted to close for that reason. It seemed to me that it would be an acceptable answer that the OP's conjecture turns out to be equivalent with something famous and open, but such an explanation should rather be given at MSE than here. For MO audience I feel that the problem is trivially equivalent to Goldbach's conjecture, but the OP and the average MSE user may not consider it as trivial.

Source Link
Joonas Ilmavirta
  • 8.1k
  • 3
  • 21
  • 47

A research-level question can also be off-topic if the community has chosen to restrict the scope of the site so. Our help pages state that questions about open problems are off-topic, so closing because of that is fine. The standard off-topic closure reason is misleading, so I suggest you vote to close under a custom reason. Choose the option "Other" under "Off-Topic" in the close vote dialogue and write what the problem is. I think this particular reason to close is not so common that we would need a separate closing reason.

I think the particular question would be much better at MSE, which is why I voted to close for that reason. It seemed to me that it would be an acceptable answer that the OP's conjecture turns out to be equivalent with something famous and open, but such an explanation should rather be given at MSE than here. For MO audience I feel that the problem is trivially equivalent to Goldbach's conjecture, but the OP and the average MSE user may not consider it as trivial.