Skip to main content
Stefan Kohl's user avatar
Stefan Kohl's user avatar
Stefan Kohl's user avatar
Stefan Kohl
Moderator
  • Member for 12 years, 1 month
  • Last seen this week
comment
Should users be shown some basic information before posting the first question?
@LSpice: If people give an honest answer yes to the question "Is this homework?", then likely making this trigger rejection is the right thing to do. Though "Is this research-level mathematics?" is different in that mathematicians will likely often hesitate to claim yes, even for quite interesting questions. So it depends.
comment
Should users be shown some basic information before posting the first question?
@j.c.: I think Scott Morrison's text is much too long. To me it seems unlikely that many new users will bother to read it, regardless of how prominently it is displayed. Rather it would just be dismissed like the common lengthy Terms of Service of any other website. This already by native speakers of English, but even more of course by others.
comment
comment
Requests for reopen and undelete votes for closed and deleted questions
I'd vote to undelete and reopen if the OP states here the intention to edit and clarify the question. On the other hand, I don't think it makes sense to re-activate an abandoned question.
comment
Have any MO-hard problems ascended to "real" open problems in their fields?
@WillSawin: As to problems in published lists of open problems -- there are e.g. a couple of questions of mine in the Kourovka Notebook which I posed first on MO.
comment
Have any MO-hard problems ascended to "real" open problems in their fields?
How do you measure how interesting a problem is? -- Is it the total amount of monetary prizes one can win for a solution, the number of times it is mentioned in the literature, the number of papers which would be "erased" by solving it?
comment
MO Twitter presence?
@JoelDavidHamkins: Additional low-quality comments would be unlikely anyway, since commenting requires 50 points.
comment
Using MO as a platform to discuss papers in math?
As you say, certainly asking occasional specific mathematical questions about particular papers on MO is no problem. -- But much more useful would be a searchable and editable database of comments and errata on papers, which would be something entirely different from MO. This could be a separate site or an extension of zbMATH / MathSciNet, or individual publishers could host the comments.
comment
Re-Posting on Math.StackExchange
Addendum: Editing a question apparently postpones autodeletion to a certain extent (but not beyond 30 days after the initial posting of the question) -- see here for the exact criteria.
comment
Non-accepted answers "better" than the accepted one - what to do?
The deleted answer was the accepted one -- that's what I mean.
comment
Non-accepted answers "better" than the accepted one - what to do?
In general, of course. -- But do you think this holds also for the particular case the question asks about?
comment
Apologies re image links update => bumping
Why don't you just do them all in one go, if they anway need to be fixed? -- Is having once 64 posts bumped more of a nuisance than having 14 times 4 or 5 posts bumped?
revised
Formatting Sandbox
[Edit removed during grace period]
Loading…
comment
Re-Posting on Math.StackExchange
As far as I know, a question without answers gets auto-deleted 9 days after being put on hold. But given Todd Trimble's comment, this may be not relevant here (moderators can undelete and reopen, if they deem it appropriate).
comment
Re-Posting on Math.StackExchange
Just the present state: the question is closed, and there are 3 pending reopen votes and 2 pending delete votes. This means that if 2 more people vote to reopen, your question gets reopened -- but if it happens earlier that one more person votes to delete, your question gets deleted. Since there is no answer, the question will be deleted as well if the reopen votes are not cast within a week from now.
comment
News of potential interest to the MO community
I think reporting any important enough result or new development in mathematics would be fine as well, and at least equally interesting as news about who has died or who has got this-or-that award.
comment
News of potential interest to the MO community
As of now, four of five answers report someone's death -- is this almost the only type of "News of potential interest to the MO community"? I do not doubt that these reports are of interest, in particular the one of today -- but would it perhaps make sense to adjust the question accordingly, as for several months hardly any other news turned up here?
reviewed
Approve
1
15 16
17
18 19
47