Hot answers tagged

38 votes

How should we react to the existence of Math Educators SE?

I am against making "questions on math education no longer on-topic here". There are some excellent education related questions on this site. We may specify that education questions on MO ...
25 votes

What to do with the erdos tag?

In order to have something to vote on, I give @FrançoisG.Dorais's three suggestions as three separate answers. Eliminate the tag entirely.
23 votes

How should we react to the existence of Math Educators SE?

I would very much like to keep questions about graduate level courses here at MO. There is a lot of knowledge of how to present various topics which isn't available in books and is only known to a few ...
23 votes
Accepted

Creation of "procrastination" tag

I agree with you completely. Meta-tags are not great, and while some are tolerable (e.g. soft-question), meta-tags that are not descriptive of the question should not exist.
  • 36k
16 votes

Should we blacklist or delete the "research" tag?

This tag already has 23 questions using it, and from the list it is clear that the usage is essentially random, with no coherent unifying themes. The only noticeable exception is that a substantial ...
15 votes

Merge complex-analysis and cv.complex-variables?

I think they should be merged, as choosing one tag instead of the other seems to convey little information. I think we should also add the expression "complex analysis" in the tag wiki excerpt of cv....
15 votes

Recent suggested tag wiki edits

The problem seems to be more serious: the tag wiki edits by this user seem to copy-paste material from sites like MathWorld, which requires a license for commercial use (http://mathworld.wolfram.com/...
12 votes

How should we react to the existence of Math Educators SE?

The Math Educators (MESE) site is still in beta, so there are a few things we can't do just yet. During the beta phase, SE sites are still defining themselves and narrowing down what is on-topic/off-...
12 votes
Accepted

Is the [completeness] tag necessary?

This seems like a reasonable thing to do. If there are no objections, then I'll set the wheels in motion. Update: After removing completeness tags by hand (from the 7 posts that used it), I had put ...
  • 51k
12 votes

Should we blacklist or delete the "research" tag?

Suggestion: Burninate the tag research (rather than remove it manually). Burnination means that the tag is removed from all questions without any bumping. (Pointers to more detailed information about ...
11 votes

Policy for Naming of Tags

I think neither "simplices" nor "simplex-theory" captures the topic that is currently described by "simplicial-stuff". If we want to rename it, maybe "simplicial-objects"? (even if taken literally is ...
  • 15.8k
11 votes
Accepted

Tags "riemann-zeta-function" and "zeta-functions" are almost identical

There are many interesting zeta functions, and the Riemann zeta function is the most notable of them. It is natural to expect that people who ask questions about other zeta functions would want a ...
  • 43.4k
9 votes

Help cleanup tags!

There is a built-in system to automatically create tag synonyms by the nomination and voting of high-reputation users. Unfortunately, it appears that hardly anyone ever looks at this page (and the ...
9 votes

What to do with the erdos tag?

In order to have something to vote on, I give @FrançoisG.Dorais's three suggestions as three separate answers. Rename to erdos-problems or similar. Perhaps multiple related tags.
8 votes

arXiv vs MathOverflow - popularity of disciplines

I guess that MO is more forgiving about discussing curious problems, or recreational mathematics, such as Stanleys question about certain chess positions for example. Problems which are easy to state ...
8 votes

Tag warnings on MO

There are several tags that are deprecated. Adding tag-warnings for them could decrease the probability that they will be added to new questions. (Tag-warnings are more visible than tag-excerpts.) I ...
8 votes

Reappearance of (topology) tag

The SE team has the ability to blacklist tags. The most efficient way to request this is probably to list all tags that should be blacklisted into a single (new) meta post "Blacklist [topology], ..." ...
  • 1,151
8 votes
Accepted

Could there be a warning when a new tag is created?

I have just received a message from the Stack Overflow Team that the Warning pop-up for new tags has been enabled.
  • 51k
8 votes
Accepted

Is it ok to ask for explanation of content in question?

Please do not ask for clarification when the content of the question is clear to specialists. The person asking the question is looking for an answer, not a discussion about basic definitions. Of ...
  • 43.4k
8 votes
Accepted

Tags for off-topic question

There is a special tag-removed option for clearly off-topic cases like this.
  • 51k
8 votes

What to do with the erdos tag?

In order to have something to vote on, I give @FrançoisG.Dorais's three suggestions as three separate answers. Leave as is. (And explain how it should be used!)
7 votes

Help cleanup tags!

As of August 8, 2017, the length limit for tags went from 25 characters to 35 characters. So now is a great time to allow inconveniently compressed tag names to stretch out a bit... Perhaps we could ...
7 votes

Currently, is it possible to have relevant question under the latex tag

I think a question along the lines of "this is a novel concept I am trying to introduce in a paper, does anyone have recommendations about how to succinctly describe it formulaically" might be on ...
7 votes
Accepted

What is the intended use of the (proofs) tag?

I don't know what the original point of this tag was, but based on the current questions with this tag and infrequent recent usage (9 total, used 5 times in 2013 and and 4 times from 2016-2018) and ...
  • 5,349
7 votes

Noncommutative rings/algebra tags

As someone who played a little with noncommutative algebra in the past I would approve this merger. In any case, something has to be done because "not necessarily commutative" does not look very ...
7 votes
Accepted

Should there be another tag for vector bundles in Algebraic geometry (over schemes)?

I don't think a new tag is necessary here. Usually, we want a new tag when a single term is used in quite different ways in different fields. Here, the concepts are essentially the same - in both ...
  • 43.4k
7 votes

Creating theories-of-arithmetic logic tag

I think having a tag for something like this would be quite reasonable. However, I have a couple reservations with your proposal. First, in my opinion "arithmetic logic" is not an ideal tag ...

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible