97 votes

Is there a way to discuss the correctness of the proof of the RH by Atiyah in MO?

After some internal discussion, the moderators have agreed to post the following text. There are calls from the community to enunciate a firm and consistent policy for what questions are permissible ...
Scott Morrison's user avatar
60 votes

Welcoming new user: on a recent question about connections

I just want to comment, I think at this point, fighting and unpleasantness about whether questions are appropriate is a much bigger problem for the site than the presence of less-advanced questions on ...
Ben Webster's user avatar
  • 42.8k
47 votes

Why was there pushback on a user's profile image?

For people who are either unfamiliar with US history (either due to growing up in other countries or who had White Supremacist textbooks in school), here are the first two paragraphs of the state of ...
Noah Snyder's user avatar
  • 27.3k
42 votes

Should these sexually suggestive jokes be kept or deleted?

I wanted to say specifically why the second joke on the list really should be deleted. There's a very common trope in math where people analogize math to an attractive woman often explicitly in a ...
Noah Snyder's user avatar
  • 27.3k
38 votes

Question about $i$ versus $-i$

This question relates directly to issues that are often discussed in the philosophy of mathematics. According to one of the standard accounts of structuralism, what mathematical objects are at bottom ...
Joel David Hamkins's user avatar
36 votes

Is there a way to discuss the correctness of the proof of the RH by Atiyah in MO?

I will take a different viewpoint than some and say that the correctness of the proof can be discussed, and maybe it should. But as to how, that's a question of tactfulness and precision. When ...
Manuel Bärenz's user avatar
35 votes

Welcoming new user: on a recent question about connections

I want to distinguish two different things that were said in the first comment: that the question was not research level and that the question should be migrated to math stackexchange. It is not ...
Will Sawin's user avatar
  • 125k
31 votes

Appropriateness of recent LIGO question for MO

It seems that the moderators' opinions are not unified on this question, so I will offer my view wearing my private citizen hat. The question asks how various parameters of an apparent black hole ...
S. Carnahan's user avatar
  • 44.3k
30 votes

On discussion of published papers at MO

A scientific paper is like a politician --- much of its reputation is based on hearsay, and superficial impression, not on cold analytic examination. Very few have willingness and time to investigate ...
Boris Bukh's user avatar
  • 7,666
28 votes

Why was the whole math jokes thread deleted, and should it have been?

I feel the deletion is a significant loss to MathOverflow. As one of a few prominent older light-hearted threads, it helped make MO an entertaining and enjoyable place — like the departmental lounge, ...
Peter LeFanu Lumsdaine's user avatar
26 votes

On discussion of published papers at MO

This meta question is phrased as a general question about the appropriateness of discussing published papers on MO. That's a fair question, but I think that it's actually quite a different question ...
Timothy Chow's user avatar
  • 72.5k
26 votes

close/reopen wars on Mathoverflow

I am profoundly opposed to the "cargo cult" question. The internet is full of places where one can indulge in the pleasures of righteous indignation by mocking the failings of others. I absolutely ...
Neil Strickland's user avatar
23 votes

Is there a way to discuss the correctness of the proof of the RH by Atiyah in MO?

I don't think there's any good solutions here, but I am going to suggest what I think is the least bad solution, and people can vote on whether it is a good idea or not. There are going to be lots of ...
arsmath's user avatar
  • 6,579
20 votes

Appropriateness of recent LIGO question for MO

My view is that what should count is the (academic/scientific interest) times (the amount of mathematics involved). So if the academic interest is huge and the mathematical component is modest we ...
Gil Kalai's user avatar
  • 24.1k
20 votes

Kitty can’t fix it — Old questions inaccessible for logged-in users, giving “unexpected error”

Thank you all for reporting and excellent documentation of this issue! We have applied a fix and all the affected pages should now load as expected for logged in users as well as anonymous users. As ...
Amanda Ryman's user avatar
19 votes

Should Kevin Buzzard's Lean question be left in its original state?

My opinion, posted as an answer here so that it is ready for the downvotes. The "background" section reads more like a blog post than a question, and I feel it's out of place on this website. You ...
Federico Poloni's user avatar
18 votes

Appropriateness of recent LIGO question for MO

I find it difficult to understand many of the comments and concerns that this question seems to have raised. The site has a fairly simple and well established procedure for closing/keeping open ...
Lucia's user avatar
  • 42.9k
18 votes

Using MathOverflow to get new results in your research and publish them afterwards

On my opinion, no general rule can be stated. But I can share my experience. I answered a MO question which was needed in someone's research. The result was two separate papers. My paper where the ...
Alexandre Eremenko's user avatar
18 votes

Welcoming new user: on a recent question about connections

I note that frequently users complain about unexplained downvotes and anonymous downvotes. Discouraging comments from users who indeed make a comment of this nature ("this is off-topic") ...
YCor's user avatar
  • 56k
17 votes

Humans, Go, Computers, Math

In addition to my comment that the thread is too "discussion-y" (meaning too opinion or speculation driven), my feeling about this question is that there is probably no one in our community who can ...
Todd Trimble's user avatar
  • 51.6k
17 votes

How is it off-topic to ask whether the normalization of a local complete intersection is Gorenstein?

As one of the users who casted a vote to close, I guess I should provide an answer. What I did not like was the lack of effort displayed in the question. The question in itself could be fine: it is ...
Olivier's user avatar
  • 9,720
16 votes

Are these close-votes cast correctly?

The close votes on your question are correct. You write it correctly that the answer on MSE seems imprecise and unsatisfactory for you. But it looks like it is actually quite precise and ...
Daniel Soltész's user avatar
16 votes

Why was "The origin(s) of the word “elliptic” migrated to hsm?

I wrote the top-voted answer to this question on MO (it currently has something like 40 up votes) and was a bit surprised to see it migrated to HSM. I don't care about votes or what-not, but in terms ...
Joe Silverman's user avatar
15 votes

On discussion of published papers at MO

I think Joseph O'Rourke meant to say something else. I will guess that something like the following is intended. MathOverflow is not a forum for judging, critiquing, or refereeing preprints or ...
14 votes

I fixed my question. Can it please be taken off hold now?

Although the question at MO has been reopened, the meta post is not completely moot: let me remind users that there is a meta thread dedicated to the requests for reopening: Requests for reopen and ...
Todd Trimble's user avatar
  • 51.6k

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible