I just reviewed an edit and rejected it because it looked wrong to me. The edit suggested a modification with respect to indices in some formula. https://mathoverflow.net/review/suggested-edits/43644. It was reviewed by two other people who accepted the edit. I feel the original post was correct and that the edit introduced an error. Can someone confirm I am not making a mistake? Assuming I don't, should I revert the edit?

I am new about the editing process. Some guidance would be welcome.

  • 8
    $\begingroup$ If you find a wrong edit, revert it. -- Besides, I think the suggested edits review queue is geared too much towards acceptance of edits. $\endgroup$ – Stefan Kohl May 15 '15 at 20:27

On the specific case, I confirm the edit is not good, as the formula has incoherent indexing [and it is just not right, too] (and I rolled it back right away).

On the general matter:

  • Edits concerning the mathematical substance of a post should only be undertaken with great care. When in doubt on a suggested edit, do not approve the edit. If you feel not competent on the matter "skip," if you feel competent "reject" (possibly with a custom reason explaining the concern.)

  • If you notice such an edit. If you are confident the edit is not good "rollback" (possibly leaving a comment; you can @-notify editors of a post even though they are not suggested in the auto-complete.) If you are unclear about the merits of an edit, comment on it (notifying the editor).


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .